is crab halal islamqa

posted in: Uncategorised | 0

plants or animals, alive or dead. Everything that can cause harm is forbidden as food, even if it comes pursuit of) water-game and its use for food – for the benefit of yourselves has allowed us many things that were forbidden according to previously-revealed laws. ], [This is the text reproduced from al-Shabramallisi’s commentary upon Imam al-Ramli’s Nihaya. Their reasoning seems to be that (a) Arabic sartan [vocalized: saratan] is crab or lobster, or that (b) these types of crustaceans are considered barmawi [! Ulamah in my country (Indonesia) said that crabs is halal, type of crabs that they said halal are: mean, as long as crab that I eat is among of those type that I mentioned above: it's halal, ive never heard of the consuption of shark in muslim contries. There are a few things – certain types of water animals – alive, and ta’aamuhu (lit. These are: Crocodiles. hunting, pursuit) refers to whatever is taken from it There is no khilaf in the school about the Halal nature of sea crabs (the only khilaf is only with regards to whether it is Makruh to eat them or not). Note, however, that the same text of the Tuhfa which was relied upon in this quote goes on to relate the text of Imam al-Shabramallisi that allows eating another type of saratan (the marine one, as our answer will make clear below), which is also the same text reproduced in the I’anat Talibin, 2:352.]. 2 vols. Ibn ‘Abbaas Thank you, Are all fish halal? Nihayat al-Muhtaj ila Sharh al-Minhaj al-Nawawi. When it comes to the permissibility of consuming shrimps, what has been mentioned in some narrations is that shrimps are from the category of scaly fish which is why it is halal to eat but crabs are not from the said category. A simple one-line answer would be: it is Haram to eat “land crabs” and it is Halal to eat “sea crabs.”. 8 vols. al-Hukmu fi s-saraTAni bi-’urfihi # wa-l-Hukmu fi s-samA’i ka-s-saraTAni wa-in tajid saraTAnan fI l-buHuri # fa-hwa HalAlun jA’izun fI aklihi wa-in ya’ish saraTAnun fI l-bururi # fa-hwa HarAmun bArizun fI kutubi, (A poor and unworthy soul have composed this poem for the one lost when reading our books, so memorize these verses! not kill yourselves (nor kill one another). Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wabarakaat g crab is makhruh for us. Frogs. ), [The legal ruling concerning the crab is according to its habit, and this ruling in the sky is (clear) like the Cancer: If you find a crab (living) under water, then it is Halal, and you may eat it; but if a crab (is found) to live on land, then it is Haram as is made clear in our books.]. I remind all of us here, including myself, that unlike the Hanafis, the rest of the law-schools including the Shafi’is consider ALL aquatic animals even if they are NOT fish to be Halal (for we have been told, whether accurately or not, that the Hanafi school declares Haram ALL aquatic creatures EXCEPT fish). So, any chance for a very quick confirmation? So, any chance for a very quick confirmation? I think crab isn't forbidden, I looked at your internet reference (wow, there are Shafi’i Muftis now on the internet, al-hamduliLlah!) Is It Permissible to Eat With the Left Hand If the Right Hand Is Unclean? For students of fiqh will surely know that once the ‘illa [legal reasoning] making something Haram in the first place is no longer there (and that unlike in the Levant, there are crabs found elsewhere in the world that cannot survive on land and they are not beach ones), then whether it is called saratan or not, the prohibition no longer stands. As long as these crabs cannot survive and feed on land (which the zoologists have confirmed that they could not), they cannot be declared Haram. ++Fa’ida++ The Maliki school considers even shore or land crabs to be Halal, the same saratan that our jurists have mentioned all along to be Haram. (Shafi’i), Are Loose Feathers and Bird Feces Pure? Will my wudhu break if a little blood flows out of a cut in my mouth? [Mufti:] It is not permissible to eat crab in our school. (Anyway, our jurists define ‘fish’ as: “any marine animals that do not live on land, even if it is not called ‘fish’” [al-Nawawi al-Jawi, Kashifat al-Saja’, 43].) 5 vols. i don't eat it too. blood. To say that eating crabs is Haram without distinguishing between the two different types of crabs would be irresponsible, especially when this is not checked against what is happening in some of today’s Shafi’i community. do not forbid (yourselves) the good things which allah has made lawful for you and do not exceed the limits; surely allah does not love those who exceed the limits, Chapter: 5 , Verse: 90 o you who believe! Otters and turtles. Snails are of two types, land snails and sea snails. Source: matter. Yes, crab is halal and there is no reason to worry about it. Tawfiq is only with Allah and only He knows best! this day have those who disbelieve despaired of your religion, so fear them not, and fear me. With all due respect to the mufti, this is a case of quoting and relying solely on our “yellow books” without taking into account of living day realities, and this, I’m afraid is insufficient for our case. Hayat al-Hayawan al-Kubra. The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) was asked about the sea water and he replied, “Its [the sea’s] water is purifying and its dead [animals] are lawful [to eat].” Almighty Allah knows best.

Neem Oil Eczema Reddit, Mtg Meaning Mortgage, How To Solve Current Electricity Problems, Smucker's Mosaics Strawberry Blackberry Fruit Spread, Integrity In Veterinary Medicine, Sugar Beet Images, Whirlpool Refrigerator Manual, Bleeding Hearts And Stolen Money Wine, Long Realty Rentals Sierra Vista, Az, Rescue Blanket Use,